Dogmatic Logo
The Canine in Conversation
contents page back to last page visited reload this page prior page in site next page in site
CONTENTS BACK RELOAD PRIOR NEXT
two dogs playing tug o' war with a bone
figure 1  

 

bone of contention. The cause of a dispute or discord. It refers specifically to a bone that is fought over by two or more dogs.reference 1 The OED says that the term derives from the use of the word bone in an earlier phrase “to cast a bone between,” which they describe as an “allusion to the strife which a bone causes between dogs.”reference 2

“Bone of contention” has been in use for two centuries, though I doubt many people think of dogs when they use it. Use remains strong, as evident in a search of the New York Times archives, with eight occurrences in 2005. Essayist George Johnson, writing on God's place in science, had some fun with the phrase. “It was on the second day at Cambridge that enlightenment dawned in the form of a testy exchange between a zoologist and a paleontologist, Richard Dawkins and Simon Conway Morris. Their bone of contention was one that scholars have been gnawing on since the days of Aquinas: whether an understanding of the universe and its glories requires the hypothesis of a God.”reference 3 Writing about scientists who work with bones opens the door. However, given that the bone of contention involves the Christian creation story, I cannot help but think also of the bone God supposedly borrowed from Adam to create Eve. Perhaps we could see that as a kind of Original Bone of Contention.

1. Holder, M. K. 2001. Animal Proverbs & Clichés. Center for the Integrative Study of Animal Behavior. Accessed Sep 19 2001 from http:// www.indiana.edu/ ~animal/ fun/ wordplay/ proverbs.html.

2. The Oxford English Dictionary Online. 2005. 3d ed. Accessed Feb 13 2006 from http:// dictionary.oed.com.

 

3. Johnson, George. 2005. Agreeing Only to Disagree on God's Place in Science. New York Times, Sept 27, 2.
line
About the illustration: Colorized version of a photograph from volume III of Hutchinson 's Dog Encyclopaedia showing two dogs playing tug-o-war with a bone.reference 4 © 2008 Jupiterimages Corporation. 4. Hutchinson, Walter. 1935. Hutchinson 's Dog Encyclopædia. London: Hutchinson & co. ltd.
see also: bone to pick; throw him a bone
cf: dogbone
Last updated: February 9, 2008
by Alec MacLeod 2001-2008  Dogmatic Technologies Oakland Creative Commons unless otherwise expressly stated, all original material of whatever nature created by Alec MacLeod and included in The Canine in Conversation and any related pages, is licensed under a Creative Commons License. Please read the Terms of Use Agreement by Alec MacLeod Dogmatic Technologies